Skip to main content

Performance Tax?

When I see something like the "Performance Rights Act" (or performance tax, as most are calling it), I can draw one of two conclusions:

1) Legacy media (and their partners in government) really don't understand that there's a fundamental flaw in their business model, and are trying to use the government to hold back the coming flood.

2) Legacy media understands perfectly well the doom that they are facing, and they are simply trying to suck all the blood out of a dying beast before moving on.

There is a very big problem if the two biggest threats to your music business are having fans that want to hear your music and having those fans who want to share it with others. I truly feel bad for radio stations. Remember when record companies would *pay them* to play their music? Now they're trying to *charge them*. Astounding.

Technically, even the idea of charging radio to play music isn't quite accurate. They want to *tax* them.

Here's my suggestion to the RIAA:

If your business model has been undermined by progress, and the there's no way to market your goods, then get out of the business. Do not use your influence in Washington to extract money from a sector where you can no longer earn it. The market is giving you very important information. That information is: you aren't needed anymore. Because you used to be an industry does not mean you always will be.

The same could be said to all legacy media companies. There was a time in our history where they did not exist. There is a time in our future where they may not exist. Legacy media companies like newspapers and record companies had a business model, because they filled a need: moving the product from producer (writer/artist/musician/reporter) to consumer. Thanks to the Internet, for good or ill, this is no longer a need, hence the business model is dying.

We still need people to create, write, report, comment, perform, sing, and play. So, we need to find the business model that works for *them*, instead of the intermediaries who used to do something useful back in the 20th century.

I know we live in the age of the bailout, but if we ask the government to step in to prevent the creative destruction of every single industry that gets overturned by the Internet, that isn't progress, it's regression.

Comments

  1. The last remaining value point that the record companies are providing is that of a reviewer. They filter through the noise of millions of hacks to find those that might have some potential. By signing those artists the DJs have a far less daunting job of filtering through a significantly smaller pool of artists and songs to determine what will best appeal to their audience.

    Perhaps the new market place will be of a reviewer, similar to money market managers. These media companies will provide (for a cost) lists of immerging artists and songs to major radio stations.

    Or more likely they will spend billions on lobbying and we'll spend the next ten years blogging and reading blogs on the subject :)

    ReplyDelete
  2. Or we'll just be shooting links of our favorite music at each other in iTunes or Zune Social or Facebook, or whatever, and we'll use our friends as reviewer instead of old men at a record company. :-)

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Crowdsourcing Curation: The Social Graph as Gatekeeper

I've written before about the compromise we tacitly agree to when amateurs take over the roles formerly held by professionsals. The Internet promotes this takeover by lowering the cost of production and transmission to near zero for nearly every user, for everything from words (blogs) to pictures (Flickr) to video (YouTube).

As Clay Shirky put it so well: As freedom to produce increases, average quality necessarily goes down. For example: Thanks to Flickr, we now have access to a mind-boggling array of beautiful pictures, but that's partly because we simply have access to a mind boggling array of pictures, period. Some of these, of course, are beautiful; but there are a lot more of Aunt Bettie's 43rd picture of a bundt cake than of an Annie Leibovitz Rolling Stone cover.

It is at this point that many people interject: "This is the problem with the internet! It's full of crap!" Many would argue that without professional producers, editors, publishers, and the …

Intellectual Property and Deflation of the Knowledge Economy

[Update: This accidentally became a series of posts on a theme.


Does Intellectual Property Law Foster Innovation?Where I question the efficacy of patent and copyright in a socially networked world.


Intellectual Property and the Deflation of the Knowledge Economy - (this post) Where I toy with the idea that the Knowledge Economy may not turn out to be much of an economy, especially when it comes to Intellectual Property


The Economic Reset Button- Where Jeff Jarvis asks Eric Schmidt whether or not this is a fundamental shift in the economic base


Innovative Deflation- Where I ask, "Is the knowledge economy ripe for growth, or is it the means by which traditional economies are shrunk?" ]

Friday night I was discussing the future of intellectual property law with some friends. My argument, in a nutshell:

Every business model relying on intellectual property law (patent and copyright) is heading for massive deflation in our lifetimes. We've seen it with the music industry and news…

COVID-19 and the Tools We Need to Re-open Wisely

There's a lot of graphs and stats that the news is throwing at people right now. So much so, that you can get information overload trying to make sense of the statistics that have meaning. To quote my old Econometrics professor, "There are three types of lies: 'Lies', 'Damned Lies', and 'Statistics' ". I should also lead with the caveat that I'm an engineer and data nerd by trade, but I'm not an epidemiologist. I welcome feedback from those who have more experience than I do.The most important question we're trying to answer (at least here in Michigan), is "How are we doing?", and "When can we reopen our economy?". With respect to those questions, here's my take on the most important data, and some caveats about what these data are telling us.The four most cited data in news stories are:Total Number of CasesDaily New Cases.Total Number of DeathsDaily New DeathsThis post will talk about #1 and #2 above. I'll …